Warner faces a surprise new bid as investors do the real math

Warner Bros. Discovery confirmed that it received an amended, unsolicited tender offer from Paramount Skydance to acquire all outstanding shares. The media giant said that under the terms of its current arrangement with Netflix, its board will consider the offer with advisors.

However, it also made one thing very plain.

That's a kind way of stating that Paramount may be louder, but Netflix is still ahead for now.

Here’s the part Wall Street keeps missing: this isn’t one deal; it’s 2 different payouts

It seems like a routine bidding war for this buyout, but the outcome for the shareholders is otherwise.

Paramount's offer is clear: $30 per share in cash for the complete firm. This is a simple "take the money and walk" exit.

Related: Nvidia makes boldest move yet, and the fallout begins

Netflix's offer is well structured, which is what makes it interesting to investors. The Netflix method is based on splitting WBD's old networks into a new firm on its own, which is typically called "Discovery Global." Then, the Netflix deal is finished around studios and streaming.

That means stockholders aren't looking at two numbers. They're looking at a package agreement and certainty.

Shareholders are making a choice between:

• Paramount: one outcome (cash)
• Netflix: multiple moving parts (cash + stock + the spinoff stake)

That's why a "lower" headline number might still win if the board thinks it ends with less drama or if the leftover spinoff turns out to be worth anything.

Paramount is betting investors want the simplest thing on Wall Street

The Paramount-Skydance offer is meant to make investors feel good by giving them full cash and saying, "No more waiting."

That's a strong statement in a market that doesn't like uncertainty, especially when you're talking about a heritage media firm where the biggest worry is that "the best assets get trapped in the wrong structure."

More Streaming:

• Paramount Warner Bros. hostile bid has a catch for cable networks
• Apple TV adds key feature Netflix dropped
• Facebook makes daring move to challenge Disney, Netflix
• Box office is booming in 2025 but Netflix’s $82.7 billion surprise raises alarms

Basically, Paramount is telling stockholders not to overthink it. Take the extra. We'll take care of the mess.

But that ease can be deceiving. A cash bid only appears "better" if the market thinks it has a favorable probability of closing. The board's refusal to move shows that risk is still important here.

Netflix’s deal comes with a ‘hidden stock’ most investors aren’t pricing correctly

Netflix's approach is not a clean escape. It's a structured payment.

When people talk about the Netflix deal, the main thing they talk about is the $27.75 per share in cash and Netflix stock, as well as the idea that shareholders would own a part of the spun-out networks firm once it is separated.

Related: Oracle just made a power move Wall Street can’t ignore

The truth for investors is that the Netflix conclusion depends on what the market thinks the spinoff is worth in the end.

If the spinoff performs poorly, shareholders may desire Paramount's funds instead. If the spinoff makes a lot of money, Netflix's "complicated" structure can actually be very competitive.

Netflix is basically saying to the market, "Studios/streaming deserve a premium multiple; networks should stand alone."

This is the real Catch-22 for shareholders

Here's the Catch-22: the transaction that appears better on paper might trade like it's worse if investors worry it won't close.

That's why fights over takeovers aren't just about pricing. They turn into conflicts of chance.

The stock will likely exhibit a combination of factors, including:

• the payment per share
• the time to finish
• the risk of rules
• and, for Netflix, the worth of the spinoff article

So, the appropriate way to frame an investor is not "30 is bigger than 27.75." It's: what's the value you expect once you take into account risk and difficulty?

What investors should watch next

We are currently in a time where little stories can make enormous changes since the market is always changing the probabilities of each occurrence.

The next thing to pay attention to is what the board says. WBD has said it will let shareholders know what it finds after its study is done. Even a small change in language can show whether Paramount's new offer is getting more support.

Related: Nvidia’s China chip problem isn’t what most investors think

Tender mechanics and deadlines are the second pressure point. Tender offers are meant to make you make a decision, and as the deadline gets closer, that sense of urgency can make the spread smaller and the stock more volatile.

How Wall Street values the spinoff is the third swing element. Netflix's structure looks more competitive if analysts start to see the network's spinoff as a real business on its own, even if the multiple is low.

If the Street thinks the spinoff is a waste of time, shareholders will find it much tougher to ignore Paramount's clean cash offer.

The winner will be determined by spreadsheet math, not Hollywood

This story looks like a streaming war, but it’s really a shareholder payout question wearing a Batman cape.

Investors can get the purest result from Paramount: cash.

Related: Intel CEO deals spark controversy, debate

Netflix is offering a more intricate payment that can be worth more, but only if the spinoff is priced reasonably and the deal goes through without any problems.

The board's current stance shows that it still thinks Netflix's path leads to the optimum risk-adjusted outcome. But if Paramount wants to change the story, it probably only has two things that matter to shareholders: boost the price or make the closing odds feel unbeatable.

Related: A $1 trillion IPO looms, and Amazon may have just locked in early