Your big family SUV might be safe for you, but it may kill other drivers

A new study exposed a common trope with supersized vehicles.

Feb 11, 2025 - 10:30
 0  6
Your big family SUV might be safe for you, but it may kill other drivers

The Philadelphia Eagles may personal won Great Bowl 59 in a victorious relate, however the merely winners in between the performs weren't any of the avid gamers out on the field.

For individuals that manufacture no longer phrase soccer, the huge recreation is for two issues: the halftime musical efficiency and the commercials, and advertisers went all out to build up viewers' consideration. This 12 months, companies spent virtually $8 million on a 30-second plight within the direction of the game, but as always, seemingly the most different memorable ads that performed to millions on TV had been for cars.

Breaking: 12 issues to know about Trump's new tariffs

Whether you most smartly-liked Glen Powell within the 'Goldilocks' advert for Ram Automobiles or Harrison Ford taking a dinky dig on the Dearborn automaker that shares his family title in a Jeep advert, each and every commercials basically showcase one traditional product: big, ol' American cars.

Over the years, big SUVs and autos were touted because the "ideal" family cars. Many everyday motorists are resulted in imagine that the larger their automobile, the safer they and their formative years shall be in a head-on collision with another automobile. Nonetheless, a present hit upon by the Insurance protection Institute for Freeway Safety (IIHS) unearths that there's some sparkling print connected to this conception that would place you and your loved ones at menace.

Undergo or no like, the IIHS finds that great, heavy pickup autos may no longer be the most gather autos.

Stellantis

Bigger doesn't always mean safer, says IIHS

According to a new hit upon by the IIHS—the similar guys who decide which cars are "top safety picks"—, there comes a level when having a bigger and heavier automobile goes against the conception that these "monsters" are mighty safer cars.

“For American drivers, the vulnerable wisdom is that if larger is safer, even larger should be safer tranquil,” IIHS President David Harkey stated. “These results relate that isn’t merely lately. No longer for individuals in assorted cars. And — right here's famous — no longer for the occupants of the substantial autos themselves.”

In prior recordsdata, the IIHS stumbled on that SUVs and pickup autos posed an outsize menace to individuals in cars partly attributable to the respective autos' crash-bright constructions weren't aligned when in a crash. Which capability, when an SUV or pickup hits a mighty smaller automobile, wherever it hits, it is miles approach previous the crumple zone of the automobile, causing the larger SUV to chase up over the hood of the smaller automobile.

The IIHS takes credit for automakers signing onto a voluntary commitment to make their autos and SUVs with power-bright constructions better aligned with smaller cars. Nonetheless, lately, mighty of the menace they pose to smaller cars they hit comes from their sheer weight.

The institute defined the "fast average" of passenger autos in its hit upon sample as 4,000 pounds. According to the institute, adding 500 pounds to cars lighter than the smartly-liked diminished the demise fee by 17 deaths per million registered autos while increasing the menace of demise by 1 demise per million within the plenty of automobile. In dissimilarity, adding 500 pounds to pickup autos above the smartly-liked weight handiest reduced the motive force demise fee by one but elevated the demise fee for crash-accomplice cars by seven.

Extra Car:

  • Dodge confirms gasoline-powered Charger Sixpack coming this summer season
  • Jeep guardian makes govt overhaul because it searches for stamp new CEO
  • Honda faces a huge recall over unhealthy instrument glitch

"There’s nothing magical about 4,000 pounds as a change of that it’s the smartly-liked weight," IIHS senior statistician Sam Monfort, and the hit upon’s lead creator, stated in an announcement. "Automobiles which are heavier than average are extra at risk of crash into autos lighter than themselves, while the reverse is merely for autos which are lighter than average. What this evaluation displays is that picking an further-heavy automobile doesn’t make you any safer, but it undoubtedly makes you a bigger risk to assorted individuals."

    As abilities evolves and automakers react to tightening safety considerations, the accelerate in direction of electrification, and the strain to stuff new cars with every automobile system and gizmo known to man, autos are unfortunately getting mighty heavier.

    According to the IIHS, the smartly-liked automobile's weight rose from 3,277 pounds between 2011 and 2016 to 3,308 pounds between 2017 and 2022. Furthermore, 97% of pickup autos between 2017 and 22 weighed higher than 4,000 pounds, in dissimilarity to 91% between 2011 and 2016. Nonetheless, SUVs, in most cases, are getting a puny bit lighter; appropriate 7.4% of SUVs in 2017 and 22 weighed higher than 5,000 pounds, in dissimilarity to 11% between 2011 and 2016.

    “It’s a sure construction that cars and SUVs are undoubtedly nearer in weight,” Harkey stated. “These numbers relate that transitioning to lighter pickups may personal big advantages too, especially since many drivers don’t exercise their autos for carrying heavy payloads.”

    Connected: Your accepted family SUV may no longer be as safe as you believe you studied

    The hit upon comes as IIHS experts stumbled on that passenger safety in some popular cars within the substantial SUV section wants to be improved.

    In June 2024, the institute examined the Ford Expedition, Chevrolet Tahoe, and Jeep Wagoneer for safety internal and outdoors the automobile.

    While the Wagoneer scored the excellent in crash protection and prevention, the IIHS emphasized that every and every person three autos lacked protection for individuals that matter to households: formative years within the motivate seat.

    “The nice mass of those substantial SUVs offers some extra protection in crashes with smaller autos, though that also approach they present extra risk to assorted avenue users,” IIHS President David Harkey beforehand stated in an announcement.

    “The flip facet of their substantial size is that there's much extra power to attend watch over when they crash into a mounted obstacle like a tree or bridge abutment or the barrier we exercise in our entrance crash assessments.”

    Within the waste, the Wagoneer became awarded the IIHS's Top Safety Pick, but it undoubtedly fell in need of its best honor attributable to of its lack of rear-seat passenger protection.

    Connected: Dilapidated fund supervisor problems dire S&P 500 warning for 2025

    What's Your Reaction?

    like

    dislike

    love

    funny

    angry

    sad

    wow